Cloud Migration or Replatforming? Choosing the Right Legacy Migration Strategy

Cloud Migration or Replatforming? Choosing the Right Legacy Migration Strategy

By Joe Rafanelli | Published on May 7th, 2025 |

In the digital era, enterprises face increasing pressure to modernize their IT infrastructure. At the heart of this transformation is the challenge of migrating to the cloud—a crucial step in achieving greater agility, scalability, and cost-efficiency. However, navigating the myriad options for legacy system migration demands a clear understanding of the available strategies and their implications. Should you choose a straightforward Lift and Shift Migration, opt for the more involved Refactoring Migration Approach, or adopt a balanced Replatforming approach?

In this blog, Macrosoft explores these options and provides a comprehensive guide to help you choose the right migration pathway tailored to your business needs.

What is Legacy System Migration and Why It Matters

Legacy system migration refers to the process of moving an enterprise’s existing applications and workloads—often built on outdated technology stacks—from on-premises data centers or private clouds to modern public or hybrid cloud environments. This process is no longer optional; according to Gartner, over 85% of large enterprises have already initiated some form of cloud migration, recognizing that outdated legacy systems inhibit innovation, agility, and responsiveness.

Yet, simply shifting workloads without a thoughtful approach can trap businesses in costly, inefficient cloud environments. That is why a strategic cloud migration approach is critical.

Case Study: AngularJS to Angular Migration

Transform Your Legacy AngularJS Systems with Seamless Modernization: A Success Story in Insurance Tech moving AngularJS to Angular

1. Lift and Shift Migration

This is the most straightforward method of migrating applications “as-is” to the cloud without changing the architecture or codebase. The primary aim is to quickly move workloads to reduce data center costs or meet urgent deadlines.

Advantages:

  • Rapid execution with minimal upfront investment.
  • Reduced disruption to business processes.
  • Simplified project management.

Challenges:

  • May replicate existing inefficiencies in the cloud.
  • Limited cost savings and scalability benefits.
  • Often requires rework later to optimize for cloud-native capabilities.

According to a 2023 McKinsey report, approximately 45% of early cloud migrations employed the lift-and-shift strategy, primarily to achieve quick cost relief and business continuity.

2. Refactoring Migration Approach

Refactoring (or re-architecting) involves redesigning portions or the entire application to leverage cloud-native services, such as microservices, serverless computing, and managed databases.

Advantages:

  • Maximizes cloud benefits including elasticity, resilience, and speed.
  • Improves application performance and scalability.
  • Supports innovation and faster feature rollouts.

Challenges:

  • Requires significant development effort and expertise.
  • Longer migration timelines.
  • Higher upfront costs.

McKinsey’s analysis indicates companies that adopt refactoring can reduce operational costs by up to 30% and improve deployment frequency by 50%, but these benefits come with increased complexity during migration.

3. Replatforming Approach

Replatforming sits between lift-and-shift and refactoring. It involves making optimizations such as switching middleware, updating databases, or containerizing applications without fully redesigning them.

Advantages:

  • Balanced time-to-market and cost.
  • Improves performance and scalability with moderate effort.
  • Decreases technical debt compared to lift-and-shift.

Challenges:

  • Still requires some application changes.
  • May not fully exploit cloud-native features.

AWS research highlights that replatforming reduces migration risks while unlocking up to 20% operational improvements compared to lift and shift.

Deciding the Right Legacy Migration Strategy for Your Business

1.      Assess Your Business Objectives

Your legacy migration strategy should align with long-term business goals. Fast-moving startups may prioritize speed and cost, favoring lift and shift. Enterprises requiring high scalability and innovation might lean towards refactoring or replatforming.

2.      Analyze Application Portfolio

Not all applications are equal. Critical, complex, or heavily customized apps may benefit from refactoring, while stable, non-critical workloads suit lift and shift. Macrosoft recommends conducting a detailed portfolio assessment to categorize applications by complexity, business priority, and cloud readiness.

3.      Mitigate Risks of Troubleshooting a Legacy System

A study by Forrester found that 60% of IT downtime is linked to troubleshooting a legacy system. Migration strategies that reduce dependencies on fragile legacy components help mitigate downtime risk during and after migration.

4.      Consider the Benefits of Digital Modernization

Beyond cost savings, the benefits of digital modernization—such as improved security, enhanced user experience, and faster innovation—should influence your cloud migration approach.

5.      Budget & Timeline Constraints

Refactoring requires higher investment and longer timelines, while lift and shift provides cost-effective quick wins. Replatforming offers a middle ground.

Best Practices for a Successful Cloud Migration Strategy

  • Comprehensive Planning: Define clear objectives, timelines, and key performance indicators.
  • Incremental Migration: Move less critical applications first to minimize business disruptions.
  • Hybrid Cloud Utilization: Use hybrid models when some workloads must remain on-premises.
  • Automation Tools: Leverage automation for testing, deployment, and monitoring.
  • Security & Compliance: Integrate security best practices from day one.

Real-World Impact: Market Insights on Legacy System Migration

  • Gartner estimates that by 2025, 85% of enterprises will have migrated at least 50% of their legacy applications to cloud or edge platforms.
  • McKinsey reports that cloud migrations, when done right, can accelerate product development cycles by 30% and reduce infrastructure costs by 20-30%.
  • Forrester’s Total Economic Impact™ study found replatforming cloud migrations deliver a 271% ROI over three years on average compared to lift and shift.

How Macrosoft Can Help You Choose the Right Migration

Choosing the optimal legacy migration strategy is essential to unlock the full potential of cloud computing. Whether you pursue a Lift and Shift Migration, Refactoring Migration Approach, or a Replatforming approach, Macrosoft’s deep expertise can help you navigate the complexities of moving a legacy application and realize the benefits of digital modernization.

We combine industry best practices, cutting-edge tools, and tailored migration frameworks to ensure your cloud journey is smooth, scalable, and successful. Contact us today to migrate your legacy application to a modernized platform.

Case Study: AngularJS to Angular Migration

Transform Your Legacy AngularJS Systems with Seamless Modernization: A Success Story in Insurance Tech moving AngularJS to Angular

Joe Rafanelli on Linkedin
Joe Rafanelli
Director of Migration Services at Macrosoft Inc
Joe Rafanelli is the Director of Migration Services at Macrosoft. In this capacity, Joe acts as the single point of contact for Macrosoft’s migration solutions. Additionally, he collaborates with internal technology analysts to understand requirements, work scope, and maintain client relationships ensuring their satisfaction .

Prior to joining Macrosoft in May 2017, Joe had a resplendent career in the Banking Industry spanning 25 years. He focused on Account Management, Project Management, Implementation Management, and Product Development for companies like JPMorgan, Citigroup and Brown Brother Harriman.

Joe is excellent at improving the client experience by driving change management projects to completion. Joe has B.S. Finance, MBA Investment Finance, Project Management certificate & Database Management certificate.
Recent Blogs

How to Virtualize your VFP Application
How to Virtualize your VFP Application
Read Blog
4 Critical Factors to consider before VB Migration
4 Critical Factors to consider before VB Migration
Read Blog
5 Prongs on Migrating Legacy VB6 Application to .NET
5 Prongs on Migrating Legacy VB6 Application to .NET
Read Blog
Automated Visual FoxPro Migration Service. Is it possible?
Automated Visual FoxPro Migration Service. Is it possible?
Read Blog
Cloud Migration or Replatforming? Choosing the Right Legacy Migration Strategy
Cloud Migration or Replatforming? Choosing the Right Legacy Migration Strategy
Read Blog